Two page spread handling #95
Labels
Is: Discussion
Is: Feature
New feature or request
Is: UX
Priority: Normal
Type: Help Wanted
Extra attention is needed
Some pages in manga are "two-page spreads" — basically, they're two pages, but they should be stitched together into one giant image. This issue is a discussion on how Magic Translator should handle them.
1. Naming conventions
Currently, Magic Translator vol/page names must be integers, and they must all be the same number of digits; by default, two digits for vols, and three for pages. Chapters are three digits as well, but they can also have a single decimal
.#
at the end (this is hardcoded).For two-page spreads, what should the page number be?
002&003.png
— I think if I didn't have Magic Translator, I would probably name the page something like this.002.png
(no page for003.png
) — The fact that it's a "two-page spread" be incidental. If we went for this approach, I don't think Magic Translator would need to change at all, but maybe there's a good reason to not do it this way.2. Project/volume/chapter/page buttons
The sizes of preview images are currently hardcoded to appear in portrait, at around 1:5 scale.
I'm not sure how loading a two page spread into the preview image would render it, or handle the thumbnail. I do know it wouldn't appear bigger than normal preview images, though.
How should two-page spreads look in their preview buttons?
Appear like a normal preview button, IE taking up the same space. This would lead to a lot of white space, since landscape images are so much shorter than portrait images.
Take up the space of two preview buttons. This would allow the thumbnail to appear at the same scale as normal page preview buttons, so the thumbnail would still be discernible.
Other
This is just a note for me that I need to make sure that two-page spreads work as expected in the extractor (start centred & zoomed out completely & have ability zoom to full size)
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: