Cycle is broken for Overlay

[basnijholt]

This used to work in v1.4.3

%%opts Curve (color=Cycle(values=['r', 'g', 'b', 'y']))
plot = [hv.Curve(np.random.rand(10)) * hv.HLine(0) for i in range(4)]
plot = hv.Overlay(plot)
plot

However this:

%%opts Curve (color=Cycle(values=['r', 'g', 'b', 'y']))
plot = (hv.Curve(np.random.rand(10)) * hv.HLine(0) * 
        hv.Curve(np.random.rand(10)) * hv.HLine(0) *
        hv.Curve(np.random.rand(10)) * hv.HLine(0) *
        hv.Curve(np.random.rand(10)) * hv.HLine(0))
plot

produces:

[philippjfr]

This is high priority, I'll investigate tomorrow.

[philippjfr]

This seems pretty bad and I don't know how this hasn't gotten caught sooner. In 1.4.3 this:

elements = [hv.Curve(np.random.rand(10)) * hv.HLine(0) for i in range(4)]
overlay = hv.Overlay(elements)
print(repr(overlay))

produces this:

:Overlay
   .Curve.I   :Curve   [x]   (y)
   .HLine.I   :HLine   [x,y]
   .Curve.II  :Curve   [x]   (y)
   .HLine.III :HLine   [x,y]
   .Curve.III :Curve   [x]   (y)
   .HLine.IV  :HLine   [x,y]
   .Curve.IV  :Curve   [x]   (y)
   .HLine.V   :HLine   [x,y]

In 1.7 it produces this:

:Overlay
   .Overlay.I   :Overlay
      .Curve.I :Curve   [x]   (y)
      .HLine.I :HLine   [x,y]
   .Overlay.II  :Overlay
      .Curve.I :Curve   [x]   (y)
      .HLine.I :HLine   [x,y]
   .Overlay.III :Overlay
      .Curve.I :Curve   [x]   (y)
      .HLine.I :HLine   [x,y]
   .Overlay.IV  :Overlay
      .Curve.I :Curve   [x]   (y)
      .HLine.I :HLine   [x,y]

Somewhere along the line we broke how Overlays are nested 😱 I'll have to bisect tomorrow to see when this happened.

[philippjfr]

My fault:

2e801dabdc730f969734026f7dbccf664cad6c5f is the first bad commit
commit 2e801dabdc730f969734026f7dbccf664cad6c5f
Author: Philipp Rudiger <[email protected]>
Date:   Wed Oct 26 00:07:42 2016 +0100

    Reimplemented Layout.from_values

[jlstevens]

Ah right..because Overlay inherits from Layout. And it has been this way since the 26th of October! At least it is not an issue that made it into any non-dev release...

[philippjfr]

Finally fixed! Closing.

[github-actions]

This issue has been automatically locked since there has not been any recent activity after it was closed. Please open a new issue for related bugs.