Switch off action doesn't work on TYBAC-006 thermostat

[Synochy]

Expected behavior

When I use the switch off action in a Scheduler card it will switch of my TYBAC-006 thermsotat.

{
"child_lock": "UNLOCK",
"current_heating_setpoint": 20,
"deadzone_temperature": 1,
"eco_mode": "OFF",
"fan_mode": "low",
"linkquality": 188,
"local_temperature": 22,
"local_temperature_calibration": -2,
"manual_mode": "ON",
"max_temperature": 25,
"max_temperature_limit": 18,
"min_temperature": 10,
"min_temperature_limit": 30,
"schedule_friday": "06:00/20.0 11:30/20.0 13:30/20.0 17:30/20.0",
"schedule_monday": "06:00/20.0 11:30/20.0 13:30/20.0 17:30/20.0",
"schedule_saturday": "06:00/20.0 11:30/20.0 13:30/20.0 17:30/20.0",
"schedule_sunday": "06:00/20.0 11:30/20.0 13:30/20.0 17:30/20.0",
"schedule_thursday": "06:00/20.0 11:30/20.0 13:30/20.0 17:30/20.0",
"schedule_tuesday": "06:00/20.0 11:30/20.0 13:30/20.0 17:30/20.0",
"schedule_wednesday": "06:00/20.0 11:30/20.0 13:30/20.0 17:30/20.0",
"state": "ON",
"system_mode": "heat",
"valve": "CLOSE"
}

Actual behavior

The scheduler send the service: climate.turn_off action but does nothing on this thermostat because it expected "state": "OFF"".

Is it possible to have the choice to use state instead of service to turn on and off a climate device ?
Is it possible to add the ECO mode too ?

[z-master42]

Can't you use the state entity to switch on and off?

[Synochy]

Yes I can use the state entity but then I can't use the scheduler crard anymore

[z-master42]

Why not? What type is the state entity? Switch? Boolean?

[Synochy]

It is a switch.
But I can't have only one schedule with my different temperature through the day and my switch off or the eco mode.
Or I did not find how to do it.

[github-actions]

This issue is stale because it has been open 30 days with no activity. Remove stale label or comment or this will be closed in 7 days

[Synochy]

Thanks to not close this issue

[nielsfaber]

If I understand the bug description correctly, your climate entity does not respond correctly to the climate.turn_off service.
Why would this be a bug on the side of scheduler?
Can you share the value of the supported_features attribute of this climate entity?

Is it possible to have the choice to use state instead of service to turn on and off a climate device ?

What is meant by this? Services (/actions) are used in HA to interact with entities and devices. There is no alternative.

[Synochy]

It is not really a bug, if you prefer you can call it a feature.
I would like scheduler to be able to send the service :

• climate:state_off
• climate:state_on
• climate:eco_mode_on
• climate:eco_mode_off

[z-master42]

I don't think this is possible because the thermostat in question doesn't support this at all and doesn't appear to be a "normal" thermostat.

Both the state entity and the eco mode entity are of binary type and are not part of the climate entity.