diff --git a/monitoring/definitions/executor.go b/monitoring/definitions/executor.go
index 346364647c8f..b196da9fa811 100644
--- a/monitoring/definitions/executor.go
+++ b/monitoring/definitions/executor.go
@@ -22,9 +22,13 @@ func Executor() *monitoring.Container {
 				Options: []string{"batches", "codeintel"},
 			},
 			{
-				Label: "Compute instance",
-				Name:  "instance",
-				Query: "label_values(node_exporter_build_info{job=\"sourcegraph-executor-nodes\"}, instance)",
+				Label:        "Compute instance",
+				Name:         "instance",
+				OptionsQuery: "label_values(node_exporter_build_info{job=\"sourcegraph-executor-nodes\"}, instance)",
+
+				// The options query can generate a massive result set that can cause issues.
+				// shared.NewNodeExporterGroup filters by job as well so this is safe to use
+				WildcardAllValue: true,
 			},
 		},
 		Groups: []monitoring.Group{
diff --git a/monitoring/definitions/git_server.go b/monitoring/definitions/git_server.go
index 80e85edcf17c..c2c5987417b0 100644
--- a/monitoring/definitions/git_server.go
+++ b/monitoring/definitions/git_server.go
@@ -27,10 +27,10 @@ func GitServer() *monitoring.Container {
 		Description: "Stores, manages, and operates Git repositories.",
 		Variables: []monitoring.ContainerVariable{
 			{
-				Label: "Shard",
-				Name:  "shard",
-				Query: "label_values(src_gitserver_exec_running, instance)",
-				Multi: true,
+				Label:        "Shard",
+				Name:         "shard",
+				OptionsQuery: "label_values(src_gitserver_exec_running, instance)",
+				Multi:        true,
 			},
 		},
 		Groups: []monitoring.Group{
diff --git a/monitoring/definitions/zoekt.go b/monitoring/definitions/zoekt.go
index 6814852658e6..fa293eea691d 100644
--- a/monitoring/definitions/zoekt.go
+++ b/monitoring/definitions/zoekt.go
@@ -24,10 +24,10 @@ func Zoekt() *monitoring.Container {
 		NoSourcegraphDebugServer: true,
 		Variables: []monitoring.ContainerVariable{
 			{
-				Label: "Instance",
-				Name:  "instance",
-				Query: "label_values(index_num_assigned, instance)",
-				Multi: true,
+				Label:        "Instance",
+				Name:         "instance",
+				OptionsQuery: "label_values(index_num_assigned, instance)",
+				Multi:        true,
 			},
 		},
 		Groups: []monitoring.Group{
diff --git a/monitoring/monitoring/monitoring.go b/monitoring/monitoring/monitoring.go
index 62c8d652536b..e386aeab62b4 100644
--- a/monitoring/monitoring/monitoring.go
+++ b/monitoring/monitoring/monitoring.go
@@ -347,13 +347,25 @@ type ContainerVariable struct {
 	// Label is a human-readable name for the variable, e.g. "Alert level"
 	Label string
 
-	// Query is the query to generate the possible values. Cannot be used in conjunction
-	// with Options
-	Query string
+	// OptionsQuery is the query to generate the possible values for this variable. Cannot
+	// be used in conjunction with Options
+	OptionsQuery string
 	// Options are the pre-defined possible values for this variable. Cannot be used in
 	// conjunction with Query
 	Options []string
 
+	// WildcardAllValue indicates to Grafana that is should NOT use Query or Options to
+	// generate a concatonated 'All' value for the variable, and use a '.*' wildcard
+	// instead. Setting this to true primarily useful if you use Query and expect it to be
+	// a large enough result set to cause issues when viewing the dashboard.
+	//
+	// We allow Grafana to generate a value by default because simply using '.*' wildcard
+	// can pull in unintended metrics if adequate filtering is not performed on the query,
+	// for example if multiple services export the same metric. If set to true, make sure
+	// the queries that use this variable perform adequate filtering to avoid pulling in
+	// unintended metrics.
+	WildcardAllValue bool
+
 	// Multi indicates whether or not to allow multi-selection for this variable filter
 	Multi bool
 }
@@ -365,7 +377,7 @@ func (c *ContainerVariable) validate() error {
 	if c.Label == "" {
 		return errors.New("ContainerVariable.Label is required")
 	}
-	if c.Query == "" && len(c.Options) == 0 {
+	if c.OptionsQuery == "" && len(c.Options) == 0 {
 		return errors.New("ContainerVariable.Query and ContainerVariable.Options cannot both be set")
 	}
 	return nil
@@ -382,29 +394,31 @@ func (c *ContainerVariable) toGrafanaTemplateVar() sdk.TemplateVar {
 		Datasource: StringPtr("Prometheus"),
 		IncludeAll: true,
 
-		AllValue: ".*",
 		// Apply the AllValue to a template variable by default
 		Current: sdk.Current{Text: &sdk.StringSliceString{Value: []string{"all"}, Valid: true}, Value: "$__all"},
 	}
 
+	if c.WildcardAllValue {
+		variable.AllValue = ".*"
+	} else {
+		// Rely on Grafana to create a union of only the values
+		// generated by the specified query.
+		//
+		// See https://grafana.com/docs/grafana/latest/variables/formatting-multi-value-variables/#multi-value-variables-with-a-prometheus-or-influxdb-data-source
+		// for more information.
+		variable.AllValue = ""
+	}
+
 	switch {
-	case c.Query != "":
+	case c.OptionsQuery != "":
 		variable.Type = "query"
-		variable.Query = c.Query
+		variable.Query = c.OptionsQuery
 		variable.Refresh = sdk.BoolInt{
 			Flag:  true,
 			Value: Int64Ptr(2), // Refresh on time range change
 		}
 		variable.Sort = 3
 
-		// Rely on Grafana to create a union of only the values
-		// generated by the specified query. Otherwise, the '.*'
-		// wildcard can pull in unintended metrics.
-		//
-		// See https://grafana.com/docs/grafana/latest/variables/formatting-multi-value-variables/#multi-value-variables-with-a-prometheus-or-influxdb-data-source
-		// for more information.
-		variable.AllValue = ""
-
 	case len(c.Options) > 0:
 		variable.Type = "custom"
 		variable.Query = strings.Join(c.Options, ",")