Executions need cleanup

[metalgearsloth]

#24150 still needs reviewing e.g.

• It needs prediction.
• It has a bunch of unnecessary null suppression.
• It copies shooting code.

Anything else this is just what I saw at a glance.

[Veritius]

i dont know why emisse merged it, i was waiting for reviews tbh

[Emisse]

worked in testing so wanted to see if players used it/liked it/if it was abused

[Veritius]

ok that's fair

[Veritius]

Additionally, I want pacifists to be able to execute with cap guns, so they can play russian roulette.

To my future self: Just add the pacifism check to the doafter function along with a damage check. Say something like "You can't bring yourself to pull the trigger!"

Though, this might be used to metagame fake cap guns. More thought needed.

[Veritius]

Also explosive projectiles should explode when you execute with them.
This includes the RPG and China Lake.

[TheGoudaMan]

There's an issue with executions: if you'll try to execute someone with empty shell the gun will shoot as if shell wasn't spent, so this needs a fix too.
The problem should go away with proper implementation of SharedGunSystem I think, because it already handles empty cases.
It's easy to make a hotfix for empty casings for current state code tho. Makes sesne to do since its already merged.

With that said, me and ppl I play with are really into this feature.
If shooting yourself/executing someone with RPG is allowed, I think we should change message "you put X muzzle in mouth" into "You feel this is a really bad/dumb idea..." for a gag

[Veritius]

Ideally, executions shouldn't repeat any of gunsystem's code.
Currently there's a bunch of weird edge cases because executions take ammo but don't actually 'fire' anything.

[TheGoudaMan]

I mean, you need to use SharedGunSystem then, maybe change it a bit so you can call some sort of event like "close shot at X"? I feel something like that would be step in right direction
Because I don't think you can use gunsystem this way now (or I don't see it yet) without running entire control flow, firing the actual round at some direction with recoil, so it makes sense to update system a bit.
Without using system you'll be missing a lot of gunplay features like opening bolt, case ejecting etc. Which isn't that bad, but if gunsystem will evolve even more in future, those edge cases will become much more apparent

[metalgearsloth]

Also another large problem is this entirely bypasses the existing system (suicidesystem) for it so you have 2 versions doing the same thing.

[UbaserB]

Also another large problem is this entirely bypasses the existing system (suicidesystem) for it so you have 2 versions doing the same thing.

Regarding this, i feel like the thing to do is remove /suicide (since executions are now the new "suicide" which is much more intuitive and enjoyable. Ghost could be kept though if you really just need to ghost quickly and you can't execute yourself, which is also still RP friendly as you can consider them as "suffering from an acute onset of catatonic SSD, at unfortunate timing."

[Emisse]

no, suicide is useful if youre stuck somewhere or for debugging

[UbaserB]

no, suicide is useful if youre stuck somewhere or for debugging

thats exactly what ghost does, which is what i mentioned.

[deltanedas]

Though, this might be used to metagame fake cap guns. More thought needed.

its already trivial to check what kind it is with 45 magnum rounds

pacifism is a mental thing so if the player ic thinks the gun is a toy they wont have a problem using it...

[Veritius]

no, suicide is useful if youre stuck somewhere or for debugging

I agree. /suicide and /ghost are useful for debugging or when your game is fucked. Executions are for dramatic finishing moves like the coup de grace of a revolution. Or Russian Roulette.

[nikthechampiongr]

I think I'll work on this.

[Veritius]

I'm already doing it

[nikthechampiongr]

I'm already doing it

Oh. Well I got carried away and just kinda did most of it already.

I won't make a pr but if you want I can just give you my changes.

I have not yet re-implemented the clumsy chance for a clown to shoot themselves, or the special modifier for melee weapons based on swing speed.

Although now it's all in shared, it is not just copying the gun system, nulls are handled properly, and the constants in the system and loc strings on a component.

[Veritius]

you might as well pr it then
while you're at it, address some other problems in this issue like china laking yourself. i was gonna do that in the same pr as the fixes

[metalgearsloth]

Still needs more work.