Windows 10 error

[fpopineau]

Hi,

Trying CCL and I get this weird error:

C:\Local\CCL\ccl-dev>wx86cl64.exe
unexpected TLS index value: wanted 16, got 17

I cannot run the binary.
This is with Microsoft Windows [version 10.0.19041.208]
Any idea what is going on here?
Thanks,

[phoe]

Which CCL version are you using?

[phoe]

Seems like a duplicate of #201

[fpopineau]

Yes, it seems a duplicate of #201
I am using the latest version of ccl 1.12: I cloned the git repo and used the binaries in
https://github.com/Clozure/ccl/releases/download/v1.12/windowsx86.zip
I can recompile the kernel, but neither the recompiled kernel nor the one downloaded can start.
I rebooted the computer in case some process was hanging around, but with no effect.

[phoe]

So the issue happens only after you recompile the kernel? Huh, interesting! Which toolchain did you use to do so?

[fpopineau]

No, it happens whether I recompile the kernel or I use the one I can download. I am not able to launch any of them, and neither 1.11.5 nor 1.11.

[fpopineau]

More on this: it is perfectly possible that I allocate the needed TLS slots, only they are not contiguous. In my case, allocation start @ 14, but 16 is unavailable and so is 64. So I don't see an easy solution but rewrite the handling of these indexes with a level of indirection.

[Alkitor]

It only happens on Windows 10 version 2004, version 1909 dosen't have this problem.

[fpopineau]

Le jeu. 14 mai 2020 à 18:15, Alkitor <[email protected]> a écrit :

It only happens on Windows 10 version 2004, version 1909 dosen't have this problem.

I suspected that but it is nice to have a confirmation. Regards,

…

[xrme]

The commit message for a079670 explains the strategy of using the slots in TEB block.

But, on 64-bit Windows, we dedicate a GPR as the TCR pointer, so I don't see why it would be necessary to reserve any TEB slots there.

A simple test would be to comment out the call to reserve_tls_slots() in lisp-kernel/pmcl-kernel.c and rebuild the lisp kernel and see if it works. (See https://github.com/Clozure/ccl/blob/master/lisp-kernel/pmcl-kernel.c#L1905)

[fpopineau]

Le jeu. 14 mai 2020 à 21:28, R. Matthew Emerson <[email protected]> a écrit :

The commit message for a079670 <a079670> explains the strategy of using the slots in TEB block. But, on 64-bit Windows, we dedicate a GPR as the TCR pointer, so I don't see why is would be necessary to reserve any TEB slots there.

I was wondering about that, but not being familiar with the code, I was not sure.

A simple test would be to comment out the call to reserve_tls_slots() in lisp-kernel/pmcl-kernel.c and rebuild the lisp kernel and see if it works. (See https://github.com/Clozure/ccl/blob/master/lisp-kernel/pmcl-kernel.c#L1905 )

$ ./wx86cl64.exe Clozure Common Lisp Version 1.12 (v1.12-4-g579ed109) WindowsX8664 For more information about CCL, please see http://ccl.clozure.com. CCL is free software. It is distributed under the terms of the Apache Licence, Version 2.0. ? It works at least to the point it was able to rebuild the image. Regards, Fabrice

[astrangeguy]

It seems to be an overly strict check fort continuous TLS indices. CCL seems to require 30-63 to be continuous, but the reserve_tls_slots() also checks if those below are reservable in one continuous block. Totally unnecessary since they get freed afterwards.

[gitthail]

I have this issue. Any help?

[astrangeguy]

You have to build from scratch for now unfortunately...

@xrme Is it possible to release an official 1.12-r1 build for windows, with just this issue fixed?

[gitthail]

Thank you

…

On Thu, 29 Oct 2020 12:34:46 -0700, astrangeguy ***@***.***> wrote: You have to build from scratch for now unfortunately... @xrme Is it possible to release an official 1.12-r1 build for windows, with just this issue fixed? -- You are receiving this because you commented. Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub: #311 (comment)

[phoe]

Seconding an official 1.12-r1 build for Windows because of #353. @xrme Is it possible for you to perform it? Can I anyhow help with this process?

[ijah4]

Expecting the official release. ccl can't work on the windows 10 20H2. Unfortunately i use ccl on some projects.

[ms4720]

Is there an update on 1.12.1 or how to get the fix deployed? I installed it from scoop on windows and it just dies. this is almost a year old and if rebuilding from source works it would be nice if the project did it once for everyone

[astrangeguy]

Not a clozure dev, but this is the build I use at work.
If you want to do a full rebuild yourself then copy the kernels and images to a new checkout, run it in a cygwin environment with mingw build-tools installed and do a (ccl:rebuild-ccl :full t)

https://github.com/astrangeguy/ccl/releases/tag/1.12

[ms4720]

I don't want to do a full rebuild, I want a working build so the scoop ccl maintainer has a reason to update the package to something that works. I do not want to manage one-offs on my laptop when a customer is not paying me to do so. I would like the maintainers to maintain the project. This is a hard fail bug, ccl does not start.

[Symbolics]

+1 for this issue. It's been going on nearly year and I've stopped testing CCL builds because of it. Ironic because for many years CCL was the 'go-to' implementation on Windows.

[xrme]

I know this issue has lingered for far too long, but I'll find time to make a release (or at the very least provide updated Windows binaries) this weekend.

[ms4720]

Thank you

[xrme]

Please see https://github.com/Clozure/ccl/releases/tag/v1.12.1

[ms4720]

Scoop installed it and (+ 1 1 ) gave me 2

Thanks for fixing this

[ElwinLuo]

Thanks for fixing this.

[fedandr]

Thanks a lot for fixing this.

[xrme]

But, on 64-bit Windows, we dedicate a GPR as the TCR pointer, so I don't see why it would be necessary to reserve any TEB slots there.

As of fa2bbe8, we don't bother to reserve (uselessly) TEB slots on 64-bit Windows.