Description

This repository was made to provide a test case for issue doctrine/orm#11448

Installation and Running

Make sure you have docker-compose and GNU Make installed.

1. make up to build the image and start the containers. Once the command outputs similar to following, you should be good to go:

===== Finished entrypoint script =====
[10-May-2024 17:58:30] NOTICE: fpm is running, pid 1
[10-May-2024 17:58:30] NOTICE: ready to handle connections

2. make case-v2.19.4 to run the previous behavior from doctrine/orm 2.19.4
3. make case-v2.19.5 to run the current behavior from doctrine/orm 2.19.5
4. make down to stop and remove the containers and its volumes

You can also run make upd instead of make up to run and build in daemon mode.

Problem

Following scenario produces a breaking change after upgrading to doctrine/orm: "2.19.5":

1. Create a Parent and Child entity which are linked via OneToMany relation. Parent relation is configured to cascade: ['persist', 'remove']
2. Delete a Child entity via $entityManager->remove($child)
3. Retrieve a Parent entity which is linked to a deleted Child via f.e. $parentRepository->find()
4. Create a new Child entity and link it to retrieved Parent entity
5. Persist that Parent entity $entityManager->persist($parent)

Previous Behavior (v2.19.4)

After calling $entityManager->flush() Child entity was deleted and a new Child was created and assigned to Parent.

docker-compose exec php-testcase bin/console app:test:case
 ---- --------- ----------------------- 
  ID   Book ID   Title                  
 ---- --------- ----------------------- 
  2    1         Page from Fixture      
  4    1         Page from Fixture      
  6    1         Page from Fixture      
  8    1         Page from Fixture      
  10   1         Page from Fixture      
  12   2         Page from Fixture      
  14   2         Page from Fixture      
  16   2         Page from Fixture      
  18   2         Page from Fixture      
  20   2         Page from Fixture      
  22   3         Page from Fixture      
  24   3         Page from Fixture      
  26   3         Page from Fixture      
  28   3         Page from Fixture      
  30   3         Page from Fixture      
  31   1         New Page from Command  
  32   1         New Page from Command  
  33   1         New Page from Command  
  34   1         New Page from Command  
  35   1         New Page from Command  
  36   2         New Page from Command  
  37   2         New Page from Command  
  38   2         New Page from Command  
  39   2         New Page from Command  
  40   2         New Page from Command  
  41   3         New Page from Command  
  42   3         New Page from Command  
  43   3         New Page from Command  
  44   3         New Page from Command  
  45   3         New Page from Command  
 ---- --------- ----------------------- 

Current Behavior (doctrine/orm v2.19.5)

After calling $entityManager->flush() Child entity is not deleted and a new Child is created and assigned to parent (remove had no effect)

docker-compose exec php-testcase bin/console app:test:case
 ---- --------- ----------------------- 
  ID   Book ID   Title                  
 ---- --------- ----------------------- 
  1    1         Page from Fixture      
  2    1         Page from Fixture      
  3    1         Page from Fixture      
  4    1         Page from Fixture      
  5    1         Page from Fixture      
  6    1         Page from Fixture      
  7    1         Page from Fixture      
  8    1         Page from Fixture      
  9    1         Page from Fixture      
  10   1         Page from Fixture      
  11   2         Page from Fixture      
  12   2         Page from Fixture      
  13   2         Page from Fixture      
  14   2         Page from Fixture      
  15   2         Page from Fixture      
  16   2         Page from Fixture      
  17   2         Page from Fixture      
  18   2         Page from Fixture      
  19   2         Page from Fixture      
  20   2         Page from Fixture      
  21   3         Page from Fixture      
  22   3         Page from Fixture      
  23   3         Page from Fixture      
  24   3         Page from Fixture      
  25   3         Page from Fixture      
  26   3         Page from Fixture      
  27   3         Page from Fixture      
  28   3         Page from Fixture      
  29   3         Page from Fixture      
  30   3         Page from Fixture      
  31   1         New Page from Command  
  32   1         New Page from Command  
  33   1         New Page from Command  
  34   1         New Page from Command  
  35   1         New Page from Command  
  36   2         New Page from Command  
  37   2         New Page from Command  
  38   2         New Page from Command  
  39   2         New Page from Command  
  40   2         New Page from Command  
  41   3         New Page from Command  
  42   3         New Page from Command  
  43   3         New Page from Command  
  44   3         New Page from Command  
  45   3         New Page from Command  
 ---- --------- ----------------------- 

Code Example

Refer to App\Command\TestCaseCommand for example scenario where the issue occurs.