Generic 3rd-party switch does not indicate 3rd-party scripts and frames are blocked

[lhindir]

Prerequisites

• I performed a cursory search of the issue tracker to avoid opening a duplicate issue
• I checked the documentation to understand that the issue I report is not a normal behavior

Description

According to gorhill/uBlock#484 (comment), using the dynamic filtering matrix to block generic 3rd-party requests includes 3rd-party scripts and frames on the backend, but the UI does not reflect this by having the scripts and frames rows inherit the red or gray fills.

Steps to Reproduce

1. Block 3rd-party requests locally or globally using the matrix UI
2. Note the 3rd-party scripts and frames rows do not inherit the red fill

uBlock Origin version

1.43.0

Browser name and version

Firefox 102.0

[gorhill]

Note the 3rd-party scripts and frames rows do not inherit the red fill

Yes by design: filling in red would suggest all is being blocked when it's only 3rd-party frames and/or 3rd-party scripts. Other types of resources are not being blocked.

I do agree that the block rules should be conveyed somehow, and that is gorhill/uBlock#544. I did some work on this months ago (using partially filled cells), but I was not satisfied with the results, so still an open issue.

[lhindir]

Note the 3rd-party scripts and frames rows do not inherit the red fill

Yes by design: filling in red would suggest all is being blocked when it's only 3rd-party frames and/or 3rd-party scripts. Other types of resources are not being blocked.

I’m confused. I’m referring to using the row simply labeled “3rd-party” to block or no-op all 3rd-party requests. Based on the comment I linked, it looks like that action includes blocking 3rd-party frames and scripts, but the UI does not reflect it.

Shouldn’t the rows labeled “3rd-party scripts” and “3rd-party frames” have the same translucent red fill indicating inheritance that the bottom rows do?

[gorhill]

Ok I see what you mean, I misunderstood.

[lhindir]

Maybe it goes without saying, but thank you for your work!